1990s: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
For all of us who snuck raw cookie dough out of the fridge, this flavor was the answer to our prayers! Ben & Jerry’s gave us this ice cream flavor as well, after getting the idea from an anonymous fan. Other brands quickly caught on, swirling chunks of cookie dough into their own vanilla ice cream.
Honorable Mention: Kids of the ’90s also grew up eating the “Ice Cream of the Future:” Dippin’ Dots!